fbpx
Adventures In Audio with Audio Masterclass
Can a butt edit sometimes be better than a crossfade?

Can a butt edit sometimes be better than a crossfade?

FREE EBOOK DOWNLOAD ►

Suppose you have made an album, in breaks you have somehow managed to take from continually upgrading your studio. You might want to make a 60-second sampler track that shows off the best of all of your work. Just the thing to take with you to MIDEM.

You could crossfade the segments together. But that can be a little messy, uncomfortable on the ear, and – let's face it – it can be the easy way out.

Butt editing therefore can be a better solution. There are no crossfades and one track can flow seamlessly into the next.

In general, the best way to do this is to edit on the first beat of the bar on each outgoing segment, and also on the first beat of the bar of each incoming segment.

Sometimes however this doesn't work. For instance, the vocal could anticipate the first beat of the bar, and you don't want to cut it off.

Here is an interesting example. The tracks are both from around 1990ish as this was a period where the beat was strong and regular, and it makes the demonstration very clear…

Ebook = Equipping Your Home Recording Studio
FREE EBOOK - Equipping Your Home Recording Studio

butt-edit.mp3

The edit comes just before 0.22.

The edit here is clean and on the beat. But the bar structure is not maintained. Here is another edit where both the outgoing and incoming segments have been edited at the start of Beat 4 of the bar…

butt-edit-better.mp3

See how much more smoothly the music flows?

In fact you can edit on any two similar points in the bar structure and this will usually work. Of course, butt editing tracks that are at very different tempi is another matter altogether.

Happy butt editing!

P.S. The tracks are Ride On Time by Black Box, and Doin' The Do by Betty Boo.

David Mellor

Acoustics & Studio Design

Acoustics & Studio Design

The NLE AudioPedia series, our video-based audio encyclopedia, is an invaluable resource for sound engineers, musicians, students, educators and all audio enthusiasts. This second installment is about Acoustics & Studio Design.

Learn more...

Add comment








David Mellor

DOWNLOAD YOUR FREE GUIDE

VIDEO COURSES FROM AUDIO MASTERCLASS

Transform Your Recording Skills All The Way To PRO STUDIO LEVEL

Play Video

Ready to take your recording to the next level? Now you can - With The Audio Masterclass Music Production and Sound Engineering Course

VIDEO COURSES FROM AUDIO MASTERCLASS

DOWNLOAD YOUR FREE GUIDE

Free Download

WAIT! Do you know how to build the best home recording studio for the lowest cost?

Download our guide to ensure you make the right choices and get the best value for money

Your home recording studio should help you make great music

And save you money in the process!

With our free guide you’ll learn how to choose the best equipment and software to build your own first-class home recording studio